🍕Pasquale's Restaurant and Pizza | Gardiner, NY

Rating: 3 Beers 🍺🍺🍺

Address: 133 Main Street, Gardiner, NY

Hours: Open 7 days a week | 11 AM – 11 PM

The Scene

Think pizza joint meets small-town diner — Italian vibes with that homey, mom-and-pop touch. A great little stop while traveling through Gardiner. The wait time was short, the food came fast, and it disappeared even faster.

The Food

I went for the Carbonara Burger — bacon, cream sauce, cheese — and it did not disappoint. The sauce was a bit heavy (and kind of hung around for a while), but it was rich, delicious, and paired beautifully with a cold beer.

The portion? Massive. Enough to enjoy later, which is always a win. The menu has plenty of tempting options, and the prices are refreshingly reasonable.

Hick Meter

A little bit — just enough small-town charm to make you smile.

Attitude

Very nice! Friendly folks, easy-going vibe, and quick service.

Cleanliness

Somewhat clean — could use a touch-up here and there, but nothing off-putting.

Bathroom Check

Didn’t use. (So… no report from the field.)

Bonuses

💌 Sign up for their emails — they actually send out great discounts!

The Final Sip

A classic small-town stop with big portions, friendly service, and plenty of flavor. If you’re hungry, this place won’t let you down — just maybe keep a napkin handy for that saucy burger.

3 Beers — good food, good people, good stop. 🍺🍺🍺